Today I’m sharing a recipe that up until now I’ve only shared with family. I’ll give you the quick version of the backstory on it. My husband grew up with an older couple living next door. They were the kind of neighbors that shared an egg or a cup of sugar when you ran out and they didn’t expect anything in return. Early in our marriage I was looking for recipes at my in-laws one day and came across this strawberry pie recipe from the neighbor. I paired it with my hubby’s grandma’s famous crust recipe and it quickly became a family favorite. Now, during strawberry season, it is not unusual for me to make 5 or 6 pies just to have enough to go around. I’ve tweaked the recipe a little bit from the original, but I still think of that neighbor lady every time I make this recipe.
One pie crust (baked according to directions)
5 cups of strawberries
1 cup sugar
1 1/2 cups water (divided)
3 ounce box of strawberry Jello
2 Tablespoons of cornstarch
The first step is to bake your crust. If you are not a baker or don’t have time to make a crust from scratch, just go to the store and buy a refrigerated pie crust to bake. I promise your pie will still turn out delicious! Bake your crust according to the directions and then set aside to cool.
While your crust is baking, combine the sugar and 1 cup of the water in a small saucepan and bring to a boil. Mix 1/2 cup water and 2 Tablespoons of cornstarch together and add to the saucepan once the sugar/water mixture comes to a boil. Reduce heat and boil gently for 5 minutes while stirring. The mixture will thicken slightly and become more clear.
After 5 minutes remove from the heat and stir in the powdered jello mix. Stir until mixed well and pour into a bowl to allow it to cool. You can set this in the refrigerator to cool a little faster if you need to.
Wash and slice your strawberries while the crust and gel are cooling. I usually halve or quarter the berries depending on how big they are. This pie tastes the best with in-season, ripe strawberries! Measure out 5 cups of berries once they are cleaned and cut up.
After the crust and gel have cooled, fold the gel mixture into the cut berries until all berries are covered.
Pour the mixture into your pie shell and refrigerate until set. It is best to let this sit overnight, but if you just can’t wait, a couple of hours in the fridge will set it up enough to enjoy.
I normally only make strawberry pies when berries are in season here in Michigan, so they are a special treat! Since it’s almost strawberry season, I thought I would finally share my recipe. I hope you enjoy it! Happy baking!